Skip to content
Go to homepageDrova logo
Regulatory & Standards Compliance

Most of Group 2's AASB S2 questions have answers. The rest need CFO judgement.

Group 2 finance teams and the advisors and auditors they call: the AASB S2 questions with settled answers, and the judgement calls left open.

Charlotte Clark-Wilson portrait
Charlotte Clark-WilsonHead of Content & Product Marketing
18 Nov
Split view of a sheltered Australian bay: a sandstone shelf and gum trees above the waterline, rocks and seaweed on the seabed below it

Mandatory sustainability reporting in Australia has reached Group 2, and the holidays are close. When the office reopens in January, a June year-end business will have six months of its first AASB S2 reporting year behind it. The questions are arriving where finance questions usually arrive: with the CFO, and with the accountant, advisor or auditor the CFO calls.

Most of the questions have a settled answer in ASIC's guidance, the auditing standard or the Corporations Act. A few don't, and those are the ones that need a finance team's judgement. Here are the answers to the questions that come up most, and where the rules stop.

 

"Are we actually in Group 2?"

 

You're in Group 2 if you prepare an annual financial report under Chapter 2M of the Corporations Act, aren't already in Group 1, and meet at least two of three tests: consolidated revenue of $200 million or more, consolidated gross assets of $500 million or more, or 250 or more employees.

Two other routes lead in for entities that prepare a Chapter 2M financial report and aren't in Group 1: being registered, or required to apply to register, under the NGER Act; and, for registered schemes, super funds and retail CCIVs, assets of $5 billion or more.

 

"When is our first report due?"

 

The report for Group 2's first year, and the auditor's report on it, are lodged with ASIC within three months of year end for disclosing entities, registered schemes and super funds, and within four months for everyone else.

For a June year-end business, that means 30 September or 31 October 2027. For a December year-end business, it's 31 March or 30 April 2028.

 

"What will the auditor look at in year one?"

 

A review, also called limited assurance, of four areas set by the auditing standard ASSA 5010:

  • governance
  • the climate risks and opportunities part of strategy
  • Scope 1 and 2 emissions
  • any statement that there are no material climate risks or opportunities, or anything similar

From year two, the review extends to every disclosure, including scenario analysis, transition plans, risk management, Scope 3 and the other metrics and targets, and the forward-looking parts of that list are what assurers are most concerned about. Under the current rules, it becomes a full audit from year four, which for Group 2 means financial years starting on or after 1 July 2029.

The AUASB is clear that a review is real work. It has said limited assurance "may not significantly reduce the work effort of the auditor compared to reasonable assurance".

The later years may change. In August 2026, Treasury consulted on options that include keeping limited assurance in place for good rather than moving to an audit. Treasury has said the changes being considered will not affect reporting for the 2026-27 financial year, and none has been approved. The assurance options are about the later move from review to audit, so the year-one review above is unaffected by them.

 

"Can we just say we have no material climate risks?"

 

Lodging climate statements that simply say there are no material climate risks or opportunities is an option for Group 3 only. A Group 2 entity prepares full climate statements, and if it concludes there are none, that conclusion is one of the four areas the auditor reviews in year one.

It also draws attention. In ASIC's review of the first Group 1 reports, the two entities in the sample that identified no climate risks or opportunities each received an emphasis of matter paragraph from their auditor. ASIC has said it intends to look at this area more closely, and has encouraged entities to keep adequate records of the process they used to identify their risks and opportunities.

 

"Do we need Scope 3 in year one?"

 

No. Transition relief lets Scope 3 be left out of the first report, and most of the Group 1 reports in ASIC's first review relied on it. ASIC says a business that relies on the relief must say so clearly, label any Scope 3 figures it publishes elsewhere as voluntary, and disclose how those figures were measured.

 

"Can the same firm help us prepare it and assure it?"

 

Within limits. Since 1 January 2026, APES 110, the profession's ethics code, has had a Part 5 for sustainability assurance, bringing independence rules to this work. What a firm can do to help prepare a report it will also review is limited, much as it is for accounts it audits, and Part 5 is where a specific service gets checked. There's also some confusion in the profession about where early work sits.

A company's sustainability auditor doesn't have to be the auditor of its financial report, although a super fund can have only one auditor. Most entities so far are choosing their financial statement auditor for both (88% of the Group 1 entities surveyed), so for many Group 2 businesses the independence question sits with a firm they already know.

 

"What will it cost, and when should we start?"

 

Audit firms expect fees for climate-related assurance and other services to run at a meaningful share of the financial statement audit fee, and possibly more for smaller entities, because there is likely to be a minimum cost whatever the size of the business.

On timing, the first Group 1 reporters' advice was to bring the auditor in 12 to 18 months before the first mandatory report. Against a September or October 2027 deadline, a June year-end business is already past that point. For a December year-end business, that window opened in September or October 2026 and runs to March or April 2027.

 

The questions without a rule behind them

 

The rules settle who's in, when it's due and what gets reviewed. They don't settle what's material, which scenarios to run, or how to turn a climate risk into a number in the accounts.

That last one trips people up. Tim Stutt of HSF Kramer, quoted in the AICD's review of the first reports, warned against treating scenario analysis as an estimate of a company's financial effects: scenarios "are hypotheticals and won't always reflect the company's anticipated financial impacts of a particular risk or opportunity". Calls like that are where an advisor earns their fee, and where a CFO's own judgement is on the line.

They go faster when the advisor and the business are looking at the same thing. In Drova, each AASB S2 clause sits with its requirements, owner, tasks, evidence and a compliance result, so the conversation can start from what's covered and what's still open.

Show me a sample AASB S2 workspace to see how it looks for a Group 2 business, clause by clause.

Open a sample AASB S2 workspace for a Group 2 business: each clause with its requirements, owner, tasks, evidence and result, so the finance team and its advisor are looking at the same thing.

See a Group 2 AASB S2 workspace, clause by clause